A Think Again Media Group publication
Gun Debunk

Do top competitive shooters have perfectly steady hands?

Shooting steadiness: the movement recorded in elite competition studies

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Updated · Gun Debunk

Shooting steadiness: the movement recorded in elite competition studies

Shooting steadiness became a moving trace in a study published in 2022 by Daniel Mon-López and colleagues. An optical system followed the aim of one elite air-pistol competitor through 360 shots. The participant had placed in the top ten at the 2020 European championship in Wroclaw and met the researchers' world-level scoring criterion. Even at that standard, the measurements described changing aim, variations in hold and differences among shots. High-level performance occurred with measurable movement; the instrument did not record a permanently stationary point.

The researchers collected six 60-shot training competition tests during preparation for the European championship. Electronic targets operated under international competition rules. The competitor's totals ranged from 573 to 583 points without decimals. An attached SCATT optical unit sampled aim-point trajectories 50 times per second during the second before each shot. Shooting steadiness therefore had a time dimension as well as a spatial one. A single final hole could supply a score, while the recorded trajectory preserved movement leading up to that result.

The investigation separated stability of hold from aiming accuracy and from movement associated with the final release. Those categories were not interchangeable. In this competitor, hold stability had only a weak relationship with performance, whereas aiming accuracy and the variable described as cleanness of triggering were more closely associated with score. The authors suggested that a high level of hold stability might be a prerequisite for elite performance without explaining every difference between individual shots. That interpretation did not imply motion had vanished. It concerned how much the remaining variation explained within one already accomplished competitor.

The sample size also constrains the finding. The 360 recorded shots came from one person, rather than 360 independent competitors. Shooting steadiness could be compared across that athlete's performances, but the design supplied no direct comparison between different elite athletes. The researchers themselves called for broader investigation of technical factors at this level.

A different primary investigation, published by Daniel Mon and colleagues in 2014, measured body movement among 46 senior male competitors at Spanish air-pistol championships. The researchers compared recordings made with each participant's pistol against recordings made with a substitute dumbbell. A force platform registered the center of pressure beneath the feet. Shooting steadiness was represented here by displacement, speed and the area occupied by that pressure trace. The experiment examined balance through an instrumented surface, rather than estimating it from the appearance of a competitor standing still.

The 2014 measurements took place during official training on the day before competition. Subsequent performance came from the competitors' official 60-shot totals. The two balance tests produced correlated results, with reported correlations ranging from 0.59 to 0.92 across the measured variables. Some movement measures also had inverse associations with competition performance, although many did not reach statistical significance. The authors' aim was validation of a measurement method. Their results support a distinction between smaller movements and no movements, while their all-male sample limits the population directly observed.

In 2022, Justyna Michalska and colleagues examined another feature of shooting steadiness: whether postural movement followed a more regular pattern. Their experiment compared eight national-level biathletes with 15 beginners and 15 people without previous rifle experience. A force plate recorded center-of-pressure changes under three laboratory conditions. The analysis used sample entropy, a measure of the regularity of the changing signal. This was not a count of target hits, and a more regular trace did not mean a motionless body. The measured phenomenon was a repeating pattern within continuing postural adjustment.

The biathletes' pressure signals were more regular than those of the other groups in the rifle-holding and aiming conditions. Ordinary quiet standing did not produce the same significant group differences. The researchers also identified important limits: the participants were rested, unlike biathletes arriving at a competition range after skiing, and aiming performance was not recorded alongside postural sway. Shooting steadiness in that experiment concerned control under a defined laboratory task. The findings cannot be turned into a direct ranking of race performance or a claim that one balance measure explains every competitive result.

A 2021 systematic review by Sina Spancken, Hannah Steingrebe and Thorsten Stein provides a broader synthesis. It brought together 14 investigations involving 268 participants across air-rifle and small-bore shooting. Elite and national-level groups differed in rifle stability and body sway, but relationships between movement and score within the best groups were inconsistent. The review distinguished differences between skill groups from differences between shots among similarly accomplished athletes. That separation helps explain why expertise and measurable movement coexist in the primary experiments. Shooting steadiness described degrees and patterns of control, with results dependent on the athlete group, the instrument and the task; perfect stillness was not the recorded achievement.

True or False?

Top-flight competitors achieve perfect steadiness.

Show the answer

The Record

Nobody achieves perfect steadiness, including Olympic and Camp Perry competitors. “Wobble area” describes the area covered by movement of the sights. High-level performance does not mean that movement disappears.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me the real story” you agree to Gun Debunk’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.