A Think Again Media Group publication
Gun Debunk

Smokeless powder and its name

Smokeless powder: the visible change recorded in 1898 and 1918

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Gun Debunk

Smokeless powder: the visible change recorded in 1898 and 1918

Smokeless powder had a name that the War Department itself challenged in its 1940 technical manual Military Explosives. The document explicitly said the material was not entirely smokeless. The name marked a reduction from black-powder smoke rather than an absolute absence: small-arms fire may produce little noticeable smoke, while artillery can still produce substantial smoke. Earlier military testimony had already made the distinction’s practical significance visible. In the Cuban campaign of 1898, Theodore Roosevelt and Major-General William R. Shafter described difficulty locating Spanish forces equipped with the newer propellant, under the conditions of particular engagements.

Roosevelt’s recollections begin with an equipment decision. In The Rough Riders, he credited Leonard Wood with obtaining Krag-Jorgensen carbines of the kind carried by regular cavalry. Roosevelt connected the choice with the advantages of smokeless powder and with the expectation that the volunteers would serve alongside the regulars. The ammunition and weapon were part of the regiment’s initial equipment arrangements. Later memories of what happened in Cuba consequently rested against a procurement decision made before the fighting, rather than on an innovation suddenly discovered in the field.

During an early engagement, Roosevelt described bullets sounding through trees while the Spanish positions remained difficult to identify. He specifically observed an absence of visible smoke marking their origin, alongside the concealment provided by dense vegetation. The trees matter to that description. He was observing enemy fire through jungle, with limited knowledge of where other American units were moving. The absence of a conspicuous powder cloud removed one possible visual clue; it did not supply him with a complete picture of the enemy’s location or the battle’s progress.

Shafter’s official campaign report supplies another contemporary perspective. Dated September 13, 1898, and reproduced in Lieutenant John H. Parker’s history of the Gatling detachment, it describes the exchange involving Grimes’s battery at El Pozo. Shafter said the Spanish artillery’s smokeless powder made its positions difficult to locate, whereas American black-powder smoke plainly marked the American battery. The comparison concerns two forces using different propellants in the same engagement. It supports the historical importance of the reduced signature without establishing that every Spanish gun emitted absolutely nothing visible.

Roosevelt made a similar distinction within the American force. He identified regular infantry and dismounted cavalry with the newer ammunition, while describing the artillery and the Second Massachusetts and Seventy-first New York volunteer infantry as using black powder. Thus a single campaign contained a mixed inventory. The transition was uneven across organizations, with an effect visible to participants. His criticism of the artillery’s difficulty entering action was forceful, but it remains a participant’s judgment, separate from Shafter’s official description of the smoke revealing a battery position.

By the First World War, supplying smokeless powder involved industrial expansion on a very different scale. Benedict Crowell’s official 1919 report, America’s Munitions 1917–1918, gives American productive capacity at the European war’s outbreak as approximately 1.5 million pounds per month. It says capacity had increased twenty-five to thirty times by American entry. These are figures reported by the Assistant Secretary of War and Director of Munitions about the production program he supervised. They document institutional supply, rather than a laboratory measurement of smoke from an individual discharge.

Crowell described new plants at Old Hickory near Nashville and at Nitro near Charleston, West Virginia. At Old Hickory, ground was broken on March 8, 1918, and the first production line began operating on July 1. The development included a settlement housing more than twenty thousand people, with schools and churches. Such details connect the military demand for smokeless powder to a substantial workforce and a purpose-built industrial community. The propellant’s adoption depended on construction, contracts and people as well as on its different appearance when fired.

The production figures require a distinction of their own. Crowell reported Old Hickory as more than ninety percent complete but only about half in operation at the armistice. At Nitro he distinguished a capacity of 625,000 pounds per day from an actual output then running at approximately 109,000 pounds. Planned scale and realized production were different quantities. The report also recorded continued black-powder manufacture. The expansion of the newer propellant did not mean its older counterpart had disappeared from military supply by November 1918.

The Army’s later terminology also distinguished the material’s name from its physical appearance. Military Explosives, published on August 29, 1940, under the Chief of Ordnance, listed finished forms including flakes, strips, pellets, sheets and cylindrical grains. The substance was not necessarily a fine dust, despite the second half of its familiar name. The publication superseded War Department Document 947 of August 14, 1919. The institutional record thus continued beyond the wartime expansion Crowell had described, retaining smokeless powder as a category while expressly qualifying what both words literally suggested.

The Question

How is smoke from smokeless powder described for small arms and artillery?

Show the answer

The Answer

Smokeless powder produces less smoke, but it is not completely smoke-free. Small-arms ammunition may create little noticeable smoke, while artillery fire can produce substantial smoke.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me the real story” you agree to Gun Debunk’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.