The Spencer repeating rifle and Lincoln’s 1863 shooting test
The Spencer repeating rifle was a lever-action rifle that Christopher Spencer designed in 1860. Wikipedia calls it the world’s first military metallic-cartridge repeating rifle, and says more than 200,000 were made in the United States between 1860 and 1869. Its best-known episode is a 1863 shooting test with President Abraham Lincoln, and the sources give that test different places and dates.
The design was patented before the war. American Rifleman’s 2013 article on the carbine gives United States Patent No. 27,393, dated March 6, 1860, granted to Christopher M. Spencer for his breechloading, repeating design. The tubular magazine sat in the buttstock and held seven rimfire cartridges. Wikipedia says the magazine first held nine rounds and was cut to seven to reduce the risk of an accidental discharge.
The Army was slow to take up the Spencer repeating rifle. Wikipedia says the Ordnance Department believed soldiers would waste ammunition by firing repeaters too fast, so it denied a government contract for such weapons. It also feared that supply trains could not carry enough cartridges, and the unit cost, several times that of a Springfield Model 1861 rifled musket, stood in the way. The department encouraged the breech-loading carbine instead, which was shorter and better suited to mounted troops.
American Rifleman’s 2009 article “Lincoln’s Rifles” tells the story from the president’s side. It says the head of the Union’s Ordnance Department sneered at the president’s request to conduct experiments with a new firearm: “What does Lincoln know about a gun?” The article says a repeater the president asked for was defective, and so was its replacement, and Lincoln dismissed the gun as fatally flawed. In mid-August 1863, Christopher Spencer came to demonstrate the Spencer repeating rifle.
The sources differ on the setting. Wikipedia says that shortly after the July 1863 Battle of Gettysburg, Spencer gained an audience with Lincoln, who invited him to a shooting match and a demonstration on the lawn of the White House. The NRA article dates the demonstration to mid-August 1863 and places the shooting at Treasury Park, with Lincoln’s son Robert and his secretary, John Hay, present.
According to the NRA article, Lincoln asked to be shown “the inwardness of the thing,” and Spencer took the rifle apart and screwed it back together, delighting the president. Lincoln took the first shot at a plank target 40 yards away, and his next shot hit the spot. Spencer then beat the president’s score. Lincoln, amused, defended his lower score by noting that Spencer was younger than he was. Hay wrote in his diary: “A wonderful gun, loading with absolutely contemptible simplicity and ease with seven balls and firing the whole readily and deliberately in less than half a minute.”
Both sources connect the test to the removal of the Ordnance chief. Wikipedia says Lincoln ordered Gen. James Wolfe Ripley to adopt the Spencer repeating rifle for production. Ripley disobeyed the order and was replaced as head of the Ordnance Department later that year. The NRA article calls the test’s most immediate and important result that Lincoln ousted Ripley, and says the chief had been foot-dragging since the beginning.
The sources give different counts. Wikipedia and the Library of Congress say more than 200,000 examples were manufactured in the United States between 1860 and 1869, by the Spencer Repeating Rifle Co. and the Burnside Rifle Co. The NRA article measures federal purchases instead: it says procurement of the Spencer repeating rifle, mostly as carbines for cavalry, eventually amounted to roughly 100,000, and calls the exact number debatable.
Wikipedia says the Navy adopted the Spencer first and the Army later, and that cavalry and mounted infantry carried it in large numbers. It names Custer’s Michigan Brigade at the Battle of Hanover and at East Cavalry Field. It also says 9,000 mounted infantrymen armed with Spencers rode around the left flank of Gen. John Bell Hood’s army at the Battle of Nashville and attacked from the rear. Wikipedia adds that the Spencer’s ammunition was waterproof and hardy, which mattered on long marches.
The National Park Service’s page for Fort Smith National Historic Site adds a western detail. The Second Kansas Cavalry, stationed at Fort Smith during the Civil War, was issued the Spencer in 1865 to replace its Sharps rifles. The NPS page gives the caliber as .56-56 and the barrel as 22 inches.
After the war, the NRA article says, veterans brought their Spencers home and saw no need to upgrade them. Gen. Grant had called them “the best breech-loading arms available.” The firm, deep in debt, was wound up in 1868 to 1869, and Winchester bought its remaining assets. The Library of Congress says the Spencer Repeating Rifle Co. was sold to the Fogerty Rifle Company in 1869 and ultimately to Winchester. Wikipedia says the company was sold to Fogerty in the late 1860s, then went to Winchester. The sources agree on the Winchester end and differ on the steps between.
Wikipedia adds that many Spencer carbines were later sold as surplus to France and used in the Franco-Prussian War in 1870.
The sources do not agree on where the 1863 shooting happened, when the demonstration took place, or how many rifles the government bought. This article reports each version with its source.
- Wikipedia, Spencer repeating rifle — en.wikipedia.org
- NRA American Rifleman, “Lincoln’s Rifles” (September 15, 2009) — www.americanrifleman.org
- NRA American Rifleman, “Excels All Others: The Spencer Carbine” (July 23, 2013) — www.americanrifleman.org
- National Park Service, 1860 Spencer Repeating Rifle, Fort Smith National Historic Site — www.nps.gov
- Library of Congress, American Firearms and Their Makers: Spencer, Stevens, Whitney — guides.loc.gov