A Think Again Media Group publication
Gun Debunk

Did the Walther P38 retire the Luger P08 on day one of WWII?

Walther P38: the long changeover from the Luger

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Gun Debunk

Walther P38: the long changeover from the Luger

Germany began looking for a replacement for the Luger P08 as early as 1927. Its existing service pistol was comparatively complex and expensive to manufacture, making a more readily produced successor attractive. The search led to the Walther P38 in 1938, a design offering similar performance while taking almost half as much time to make. Developed by Carl Walther GmbH as the Wehrmacht's new service pistol, it was a 9mm semi-automatic weapon.

The Army requested an alteration before mass production. Walther's first submitted design had a locked breech and a hidden hammer, but the military wanted an external hammer. The concept was accepted in 1938; the first 1,000 zero-series pistols were delivered on June 5, 1939. At its Zella-Mehlis plant, Walther made three series identified by a zero prefix in their serial numbers. The third series resolved the problems for the German Army. Mass production started in mid-1940 under Walther's military production identification code 480.

The Walther P38 incorporated a double-action/single-action trigger design, a locked breech, and a loaded-chamber indicator. These features distinguished its design from earlier Walther pistols, including the PPK. They formed part of a military procurement project whose success depended on more than adopting a new model name. The Army had requested changes to the submitted design, and prototype production preceded the move to large-scale manufacture. The resulting pistol was intended to offer a less complex and less expensive successor to the Luger, but introducing it required factories to change what they produced.

Changing production lines to the new pistol took longer than expected. The P08 remained in production during World War II, while Luger examples stayed in service through the end of the war. At the same time, production of the replacement spread beyond Walther. Mauser and Spreewerk also manufactured the pistol during World War II, adding their own output to Walther's work at Zella-Mehlis.

Wartime Walther P38 markings concealed the manufacturers' names behind letter codes. Walther used ac, Mauser used byf, and Spreewerk used cyq. Walther and Mauser included production dates with their codes; Spreewerk omitted dates. Consecutively numbered blocks of 10,000 pistols received successive letter suffixes to conceal production volume. Total wartime output reached 1,277,680: Walther made 617,585 at Zella-Mehlis, Mauser produced 372,875 at Oberndorf, and Spreewerk Grottau contributed 287,220. Late in the war, Spreewerk's marking die broke, making subsequent cyq markings appear as cvq. About 31,400 pistols carried that altered marking before Spreewerk production ended in April 1945.

Grip materials varied across production. Early Walther P38 pistols had walnut grips, later replaced by Bakelite. From 1945 to 1946, several thousand pistols were assembled for the French armed forces with parkerized finishes and gray sheet-metal grips. Collectors called these examples "Gray Ghosts." The pistol also appeared in chamberings beyond its principal military cartridge: some 7.65mm Parabellum and .22 Long Rifle versions were manufactured and sold. Experimental .45 ACP and .38 Super versions were developed but never entered mass production.

West Germany's effort to rebuild its military brought the Walther P38 back into production. Walther prepared new engineering drawings and machine tools, using wartime pistols as models. When the Bundeswehr announced that it wanted the pistol as its official sidearm, the company resumed manufacture within two years. Deliveries to the West German military began in June 1957, and the pistol again served as the standard sidearm from 1957 to 1963. In late 1963, the military adopted the postwar P1 model, identifiable by its slide stamping. Most postwar pistols marked P38 or P1 had aluminum frames, although a limited number retained steel frames. Postwar P1 grips were made of black plastic.

Changes to the postwar design continued in June 1975, when a hex bolt above the trigger guard reinforced the aluminum frame and a modified, stronger slide was introduced. During the 1990s, the German military began replacing the P1 with the P8, completing the phaseout in 2004. Another development, the improved P4, produced from 1975, found police users in South Africa, Rhineland-Palatinate, and Baden-Württemberg. Sweden had bought the earlier HP version in 1939 and also used pistols confiscated from German forces during World War II. In West Berlin, police used French-made Manurhin pistols because of treaty restrictions.

Acceptance of a design in 1938 was followed by prototype manufacture and then mass production in 1940.

True or False?

The Walther P38 was intended to replace the Luger in Wehrmacht service.

Show the answer

The Record

The P38 was intended to replace the Luger P08, but Lugers remained in German service through the end of World War II.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me the real story” you agree to Gun Debunk’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.