A Think Again Media Group publication
Gun Debunk

Is the Browning Hi-Power a double-action pistol?

Browning Hi-Power: a single-action pistol across several dated designs

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Gun Debunk

Browning Hi-Power: a single-action pistol across several dated designs

In July 1995, American Rifleman's examination of a .40 S&W Browning Hi-Power identified the pistol as single-action and semi-automatic. Its magazine held ten cartridges. The staff compared its heavier slide and barrel with the familiar 9 mm version and reported an additional locking lug. A change of cartridge and several strengthened components had left the trigger classification intact. The standard pistol's name, its magazine capacity and its trigger action described different features, and this contemporary examination recorded them separately on a specific production model.

The design's earlier paperwork requires another distinction. John M. Browning filed United States patent 1,618,510 on 28 June 1923; it was issued on 22 February 1927. The heading called it an automatic firearm, but Browning defined the class more precisely: recoil performed the mechanical operations except for operation of the trigger. His description required another trigger movement for another shot. The historical heading therefore covered a self-loading design. It did not describe a pistol continuously discharging its magazine under one sustained trigger pull, and it did not identify the finished Browning Hi-Power of 1935.

Browning's patent also depicted a spring-driven firing pin and removable breech components. Its figures show a design stage rather than an unchanged drawing of every later production feature. The patent's stated goals included strength, simplicity, reliability and economical manufacture, with fewer parts performing multiple functions. Those were objectives claimed by the inventor. The Browning Hi-Power's eventual exposed-hammer form belonged to the subsequent development history. The 1923 application and 1927 grant preserve what Browning submitted, while the later service pistol reflects further work after that application had entered the patent system.

American Rifleman's historical treatment, published in 2020, places that work within a French service-pistol requirement issued in 1921. It describes a requested magazine capacity of at least ten cartridges and a magazine-disconnect device. At FN, Dieudonné Saive worked with Browning on the project. French trials and changing requirements continued during the 1920s without an order. The developing pistol used a double-column magazine and a short-recoil system. Browning died in 1926, leaving Saive to continue it. Further development followed the expiry of Colt's M1911 patents in 1928; a final form appeared in 1934, and Belgium adopted it in 1935. The completed Browning Hi-Power therefore followed both the original application and several further years of development.

The same retrospective describes the design's wartime use on both sides and continued production at FN under German control. A surviving postwar specimen offers more direct, object-specific evidence. The Australian War Memorial's L9A1, accession REL/16179.001, was made in Belgium around 1960 and issued to the Royal Australian Air Force. Its slide carries FN's Belgian manufacturer's inscription and Browning's patent marking. The catalogue describes an exposed hammer, black chequered grips, a ramp rear sight and provision for a shoulder stock. It identifies the Browning Hi-Power as semi-automatic and as a type used during service in Vietnam.

The Browning Hi-Power specimen's rear sight is graduated to 500 yards. That number describes its sight markings; the catalogue's Vietnam association identifies a type used on service, without identifying this particular pistol with a named airman's deployment. The approximate date of manufacture and documented RAAF issue concern the individual object.

The 1995 .40-calibre examination captures a later commercial transition at close range. The model had been announced at the 1993 SHOT Show, with quantities reaching buyers in August 1994. An early recall concerned chamber specifications, and deliveries resumed in earnest in December 1994. The tested pistol was manufactured in Belgium and assembled in Portugal. Staff described a black matte finish, ambidextrous safety levers and a retained magazine safety, together with a firing-pin block. This contemporary Browning Hi-Power specimen was a production development of the established single-action design, with a different cartridge and matching structural changes.

British procurement eventually recorded a different transition: replacement. On 11 January 2013, the Ministry of Defence announced more than 25,000 Glock 17 Gen4 pistols to replace its Browning L9A1s. The announcement compared the Glock's 17-round magazine with the Browning's 13. It also specified more than 25,000 holsters through a contract with Viking Arms of Harrogate. These figures belonged to the British service replacement, rather than the ten-round .40-calibre specimen examined in 1995. Different Browning Hi-Power configurations could carry different magazine figures while retaining the established design's single-action identity.

The Ministry gave maintenance costs and more than 40 years of British service as the background to replacement. It said the tender had begun two years earlier and did not result from a particular new or increased threat. Deliveries were planned across all three services, with personnel in Afghanistan among the first recipients. The Browning Hi-Power's British service ending was thus documented through a procurement timetable and an explanation of ageing equipment. Its long career had encompassed different chamberings, finishes, fittings and production arrangements without making the standard pistol a double-action design.

True or False?

The Browning Hi-Power is a double-action pistol.

Show the answer

The Record

It's single-action, semi-automatic — chambered in 9×19mm Parabellum and .40 S&W. "High Power" refers to the magazine, not the trigger: 13 rounds, nearly twice what rivals like the Walther P38 or Colt M1911 held. The design was John Browning's, but he died in 1926 — years before it was finished. Dieudonné Saive completed it at FN Herstal. From 1935 until the 15-round MAB PA-15 arrived in 1966, it was the only 9mm semi-auto with a double-stack detachable box magazine. The Hi-Power's magazine capacity and its single-action trigger are separate features.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me the real story” you agree to Gun Debunk’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.