A Think Again Media Group publication
Gun Debunk

When "The Gun That Won the West" became a slogan

The Winchester Model 1873 and when it became the gun that won the West

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Gun Debunk

The Winchester Model 1873 and when it became the gun that won the West

The Winchester Model 1873 is closely associated with the phrase "The Gun That Won the West," but the rifle and the slogan belong to different moments. Winchester's own historical timeline dates the rifle's introduction to 1873. American Rifleman credits the advertising phrase to Winchester engineer Edwin Pugsley in 1919, 46 years later. That chronology places the slogan well after the model's introduction, rather than alongside its arrival on the frontier.

The rifle came first. Winchester introduced what it initially called the New Model of 1873 alongside a new centerfire cartridge, the .44-40, which Wikipedia describes as the first centerfire cartridge Winchester manufactured. American Rifleman lists four offerings: a Sporting Rifle, a Special Sporting Rifle, a carbine and a full-stocked military musket. Wikipedia groups the gun into three broader variations, rifle, carbine and musket, and says the musket accounted for less than 5 percent of production. The two descriptions count the sporting versions differently.

The early publicity used other language. American Rifleman reports that the Winchester Model 1873 appeared on the cover of the company's 1875 catalog. Winchester's historical timeline also records a personal testimonial from William F. "Buffalo Bill" Cody in that catalog. HistoryNet quotes his endorsement: "For hunting, I pronounce your improved Winchester the boss." The endorsement documents praise for the rifle in its own era; it does not contain the later winning-the-West slogan.

American Rifleman's account puts the famous headline in an international Winchester marketing campaign in 1919. It identifies Pugsley as an engineer who later became the company's vice president. The article also leaves open whether he meant the Model 1873 specifically, even though that model became closely linked to the phrase. The distinction matters: the account dates the advertising campaign and attributes its headline, without identifying the rifle as Pugsley's certain, exclusive subject.

Colt's Single Action Army had its own connection to the words. HistoryNet states that both Winchester and Colt eventually claimed the winning-the-West title for their respective Models 1873. Colt's own timeline identifies its revolver as the Single Action Army, Peacemaker and Colt 45, and also associates it with the same slogan. The company's chronology dates its introduction to 1873 and records a U.S. government contract establishing it as the standard military service revolver.

The rifle and revolver also had a historical connection through ammunition. Wikipedia describes the Colt Frontier Six-Shooter as a version chambered for Winchester's .44-40 cartridge, matching the cartridge of the Model 1873 rifle. Its account says owners in the Far West appreciated having one caliber for both. That relationship helps explain why histories discuss the two firearms together, although they were products of separate companies and were different kinds of firearm.

The Peacemaker name has a separate story. American Rifleman describes it as a non-factory nickname associated with the Single Action Army by the distributor B. Kittredge and Company. Samuel Colt himself did not live to see that revolver's introduction: Colt's timeline records his death in 1862, 11 years before the model appeared. The later revolver and its publicity therefore belong to the history of his company after its founder's death.

Film gave the rifle and its slogan another public setting. The American Film Institute records the 1950 release Winchester '73, starring James Stewart and directed by Anthony Mann. Its catalog transcribes the film's opening foreword, which identifies the Model 1873 with the winning-the-West phrase. The words were thus part of the film's presentation of the rifle, decades after the marketing campaign described by American Rifleman. They were a retrospective description in that setting, too.

A separate film used the phrase as its title. The American Film Institute dates The Gun That Won the West to September 1955, lists William Castle as director, and identifies Dennis Morgan's character as Jim Bridger. Those credits establish the title's later screen use. They do not date the original advertising slogan, which American Rifleman's account places in 1919.

A surviving Winchester Model 1873 supplies a different kind of historical evidence. National Park Service archaeologists found one at Great Basin National Park during a survey in November 2014. Winchester records held at the Buffalo Bill Center of the West identified its manufacture and shipping date as 1882. The park's report says no record identified its buyer or shipping destination. Conservators examined the fragile artifact and stabilized its wood while preserving its weathered condition. The rifle's documented age could be established even though its owner's identity and the circumstances of its abandonment remained unresolved.

The Winchester Model 1873 was therefore a firearm of the frontier period before it became the subject of later advertising and films. The 1873 introduction and the 1919 slogan attribution describe separate events. Keeping those dates separate preserves the distinction between the rifle's original history and the publicity attached to it afterward.

True or False?

Winchester began calling its Model 1873 "The Gun That Won the West" while the rifle was new on the frontier.

Show the answer

The Record

False. American Rifleman credits the slogan to Winchester engineer Edwin Pugsley in 1919, more than four decades after the rifle appeared; Colt later claimed the same title for its Single Action Army.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me the real story” you agree to Gun Debunk’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.