A Think Again Media Group publication
Gun Debunk

Was "trench gun" ever an official military term?

The trench gun in the 1918 diplomatic record

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Gun Debunk

The trench gun in the 1918 diplomatic record

The trench gun had military service without that familiar phrase becoming its formal U.S. designation. Three government documents put the distinction in focus: the German protest transmitted in September 1918, the American reply, and the War Department's published history of wartime procurement. Their terminology is less dramatic than the later nickname. They describe shotguns, including repeating shotguns with bayonets. The documents also preserve different institutional concerns: diplomatic threats, continued military use and purchases from commercial manufacturers.

On 19 September 1918, the Swiss chargé in Washington, Oederlin, delivered the substance of a cablegram received from the Swiss Foreign Office. Switzerland represented German interests in the United States. The transmitted German protest objected to American use of shotguns and threatened the lives of prisoners possessing either the guns or their ammunition. It cited provision 23(e) of the Hague convention concerning land warfare. The message required a cable reply before 1 October. It did not identify a Winchester model, describe a bayonet assembly or introduce an official category named trench gun.

The covering message also distinguished the cablegram from a fuller German note verbale still on its way to the United States. That detail fixes exactly what the State Department possessed at this point: a neutral intermediary's transmission of the German demand. The dated memorandum is evidence of the protest and its threat, rather than a field report describing how often American troops carried shotguns. No procurement totals or estimates of combat effectiveness appear in it. Its immediate purpose was to obtain the American government's response through the same diplomatic channel.

That response came on 28 September. The Secretary of State acknowledged Oederlin's 19 September memorandum and rejected the German interpretation of the cited Hague provision. The reply described the shotgun as a weapon already present in the American Army and asserted that comparison with other accepted weapons left no reasonable basis for the protest. It stated that American use would continue. The language remained generic: shotguns and shotgun ammunition. Neither trench shotgun nor trench gun appeared as a formal model name in this exchange.

The American reply then addressed the threat against prisoners directly. If Germany carried it out even once, the United States announced its intention to retaliate in order to protect American forces. That was a conditional diplomatic warning. The document did not report an execution or an actual reprisal, and its forceful language cannot supply evidence that either event occurred. The dispute concerned a category of weapon and the treatment of captured personnel; it did not confer a new equipment designation on the firearms involved.

Benedict Crowell's America's Munitions 1917-1918, published by the Government Printing Office in 1919, gives the procurement side. Crowell was Assistant Secretary of War and Director of Munitions. His report put the number of short-barrel shotguns obtained from commercial manufacturers between 30,000 and 40,000. It described their principal intended purpose as arming guards over German prisoners, while acknowledging that some reached actual fighting. That is a broader total than the number sent into trenches, and the report does not identify every purchased shotgun as a bayonet-equipped Winchester.

Crowell's illustration captions name both Remington and Winchester repeating shotguns equipped with bayonets. Their wording connects manufacturer and equipment without using the later trench gun label. The report also contains a revealing error: its brief description of the German protest refers to the Geneva Convention. Oederlin's actual September memorandum explicitly cites the Hague convention. The discrepancy limits the procurement history's authority on the diplomatic details. The dated correspondence supplies the treaty reference; Crowell supplies the department's purchasing summary and its description of intended service.

A surviving firearm carries a different kind of military evidence. The National Firearms Museum catalogues Winchester specimen E690242 and records U.S. Army Ordnance proof marks on it. The catalogue calls it a slide-action trench shotgun and mentions the nickname trench broom. Those are the museum's descriptive terms for a physical object bearing military marks. An Ordnance mark and a modern catalogue heading perform different jobs: one belongs to the firearm's testing history, while the other identifies it within a later collection. The latter is not itself a wartime naming order.

Jonathon Krisko and Andrew Stolinski's later archival study adds an especially useful qualification. They found the expression in Infantry Board reports from 1921 and 1922, where the test firearm was described as a Winchester Model 1897 with trench in quotation marks alongside riot gun. Informal wording could therefore occur inside an official document. Their research distinguishes that usage from a formal designation, identifying riot gun with bayonet adapter among the terminology in Ordnance and American Expeditionary Forces correspondence. The distinction leaves room for contemporary speech while preserving what the government actually called its equipment.

True or False?

"Trench gun" and "trench shotgun" were official U.S. military terms.

Show the answer

The Record

The familiar phrase does not appear as an official designation. The term was never an official designation, despite becoming the go-to phrase for any bayonet-capable shotgun you can point at. It appears to be largely a collector's shortcut, drawn from sensational news coverage of the era and informal soldier-talk that ran during the war and kept running after it.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me the real story” you agree to Gun Debunk’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.