The Hague declaration and the expanding-bullet agreement of 1899
The Hague declaration on expanding bullets was signed on July 29, 1899. It addressed a specific category of ammunition within a much wider peace conference. The agreement was separate from the conventions signed at Geneva, and it did not precede the first Geneva Convention: that earlier treaty dated from August 22, 1864. The history runs through three distinct diplomatic projects, concerning care for wounded soldiers, limits on certain projectiles, and an international framework for settling disputes and regulating warfare.
The 1864 Geneva Convention concerned the treatment of wounded members of armies in the field. It protected military hospitals and ambulances while they contained sick or wounded people. Hospital personnel, including medical, administrative and transport staff and chaplains, shared that protection while performing their duties. The convention also made provision for personnel continuing their work after an occupying army arrived. Its central concern was the status of people and institutions providing care during a conflict. Ratifications were exchanged on June 22, 1865, when the convention entered into force. The United States joined later: presidential accession and Senate consent came in March 1882, Switzerland accepted the accession in June, and the President proclaimed it in July. Later conventions in 1906, 1929 and 1949 superseded the agreement between their parties.
Protection extended beyond military establishments. Inhabitants who brought assistance to wounded soldiers were to be respected and remain free. Commanders were to inform civilians about that protection. Wounded or sick soldiers were to receive care regardless of their nationality. A uniform identifying flag and an armband would display a red cross against a white background. The national flag was to accompany the distinctive flag. These provisions established an emblem and protected activities; they did not contain the later expanding-bullet agreement.
In 1868, an international military commission assembled at Saint Petersburg at Russia's initiative. Its declaration set out the principle that military necessity had limits imposed by humanity. The stated legitimate purpose of war was to weaken an enemy's military forces. Weapons that added unnecessary suffering exceeded that purpose. The declaration translated that reasoning into a restriction on military or naval use of projectiles weighing less than 400 grams when they were explosive or contained specified incendiary substances.
The Saint Petersburg agreement bound its contracting or acceding parties in wars among themselves. It did not apply in the same way against states outside the agreement, and its obligation ceased if an outside state joined one of the belligerents. The signatories also contemplated future discussions as scientific developments changed armaments. The combination of a humanitarian principle, a defined technical category and conditions concerning participating states would recur in the later Hague declaration.
The Hague peace conference met from May 18 to July 29, 1899, at the Royal House in the Wood in the Netherlands. Russia had called for the conference, and the Netherlands government issued the invitation. Its final act listed three conventions: peaceful adjustment of international differences, laws and customs of war on land, and adaptation of the 1864 Geneva principles to warfare at sea. Three additional declarations addressed projectiles launched from balloons, projectiles intended solely to spread certain gases, and expanding bullets.
The expanding-bullet declaration referred expressly to the sentiments of the Saint Petersburg agreement. It committed contracting parties to abstain from bullets that readily expanded or flattened in the body. Its examples concerned the relationship between a projectile's outer envelope and its core. The agreement's subject was expansion, whereas the 1868 declaration specified explosive or incendiary projectiles below a weight threshold. Those categories arose in related diplomatic efforts but were separately defined in the two agreements.
The Hague declaration also had its own procedures. Ratifications were to be deposited at The Hague, with certified copies of the record transmitted through diplomatic channels. States that had not signed could join by notifying the Netherlands government, which would inform the other parties. A state withdrawing from the declaration had to provide written notification; withdrawal would take effect a year later and affect that state alone. Like the earlier Saint Petersburg agreement, the original declaration specified conditions concerning wars between contracting powers and participation by outside powers.
The wider conference made proposals beyond the binding agreements. It expressed support for reducing military expenditure and called for further study of neutral states' rights and duties. It also proposed renewed consideration of limits on armaments, private property in naval warfare and bombardment by naval forces. A separate wish called for a conference to revise the Geneva Convention. The resulting diplomatic landscape included humanitarian care, weapons restrictions and methods of resolving international disputes, with the expanding-bullet declaration occupying one defined place among those efforts.
- Yale Law School, Avalon Project: expanding-bullet declaration, July 29, 1899 — avalon.law.yale.edu
- Yale Law School, Avalon Project: Declaration of Saint Petersburg, 1868 — avalon.law.yale.edu
- Yale Law School, Avalon Project: Geneva Convention, August 22, 1864 — avalon.law.yale.edu
- Yale Law School, Avalon Project: Final Act of the Hague Peace Conference, 1899 — avalon.law.yale.edu